Our Story

Opened August 18, 2005 by Katie Proctor and her mother Kris, PenPals offers big city shopping with hometown service. PenPals showcases Katie's funky and fresh style while bringing etiquette and class to a new level. An only child, Katie was raised in an old fashion home that emphasized the importance of personal touches wherever they could be made and that is the philosophy she has based PenPals on. Katie and PenPals prides themselves on their outstanding customer service, their extensive knowledge of the lines they carry and their fabulous turn around time.  Fast forward 10 years, a husband, a son, a baby on the way and a staff of 10 Katie and PenPals still continues to offer the same outstanding service and unique products.  With our new website we hope to expand to those customers who may not make it to Evansville, Indiana all that often or for that matter ever.  Our inventory changes daily so check back often to see what is new.  Thank you for shopping with us and for continuing to make Katie's dream a reality!  




If in the area please visit us at 6219 Vogel Road Suite 101 Evansville, Indiana 47715